Ron Paul: Obamacare will Damage Doctor-Patient Relationship

Obamacare will further damage the doctor-patient relationship, and if it were a good program, it wouldn’t have to be imposed by force.

Channel: Fox Business
Date: 03/22/2010


David Asman: Man who spent his life fighting for the freedom to choose life is Ron Paul. He’s a medical doctor by training and congressman by the will of the voters. Congressman Paul, joining us now. Great to see you Congressman, thanks for being here.

Ron Paul: Thank you David, good to be with you.

David Asman: You know, I don’t get your views very often as a physician on this. You’ve got wonderful views as a libertarian on this issue. What do you think about what happened last night as a doctor?

Ron Paul: Well, I think it’s going to ruin the doctor-patient relationship. It’s already been severely undermined because doctors don’t deal with patients, they deal with insurance companies and the government and drug companies and the whole works. So this just makes it that much worse. It’s not all at once. It’s been coming this way a long time. When I practiced medicine in the 1960s and 1970s before I came to Congress, I refused to deal with third parties. If they were on Medicare or Medicaid, if they collected the money from the government that was okay, but I consider something very very important in medicine, and that is the doctor-patient relationship. We should not be taking orders from somebody else, yet today it’s very bureaucratic and this bill is going to make it much much worse. Which means the patients are going to be less happy and the doctors will be less satisfied. Most people think people go into medicine only for the money. But I’ll tell you what, a lot of us enjoy the fact that we can deal with our patients and the bureaucracy ruins that. And I’m afraid this will make it much worse.

David Asman: I remember very clearly when I was a kid the doctor coming for house calls, my father walking the doctor to the door, pulling out his wallet, giving the doctor a 10 dollar bill or 20 dollar bill, whatever it was. Now that’s in the past. You can’t go back in the past. But whenever we can get closer to the ideal that we used to live by, the better, as far as I’m concerned. What about you?

Ron Paul: Well of course. And ironically, a little bit of that is coming back. Some of the doctors who refuse to participate and opt out, those who are still doing family medicine, will go out and make house calls and take appointments and just charge 35 dollars. They don’t do any insurance or any bureaucracy. They don’t carry any malpractice insurance, the whole works, and the patients are happy with it. But that’s just far in between because you need a hospital to deliver babies and do surgery. You need to be in the hospital so that drags you in the system.

You know, during this debate, they talked a whole lot about the public option. I just wish they would protect the private option. Give us a chance to have it private. Just like you should have a chance to have private education and home schooling. You should always protect that in spite of the disaster in public education. If you always had a private option in medicine, some of us could survive and at least we could set an example for the type of medicine that the people should be getting.

David Asman: But now, the private option as you described it and as we both, I think a lot of Americans wanted to return, it’s going to be illegal. And not only will it be illegal, because everybody will be forced to buy insurance, but you’re going to have an IRS agent on your tail if you dare not to have insurance. What do you think of that?

Ron Paul: This is horrible because the people who are going to get charged are the ones who might not have carried insurance on purpose or would have had a major medical policy and they didn’t want a big insurance policy. Insurance policies should be variable. You know, just like we buy for our houses and our car, we look at what kind of coverage we want. In medicine, the people who need the least and would carry the least amount of insurance will be the ones who will have to pay the maximum, and they are the ones who will be hounded by the IRS.

This is a command society now and medicine is right in the forefront of this. I think symbolically, the American people didn’t have concerns, now they just think about it. 16,500 armed bureaucrats coming to make this program work. If it is a good program and everybody liked it, you wouldn’t need 16,500 thugs coming with their guns and putting you in jail if you didn’t follow all the rules.

David Asman: Exactly. I think you just said it. If it was a good program, you wouldn’t need coercion. This is a coercion. Using the power of the state as a coercive body rather than as a representative of the American people’s will. There’s something deeply, deeply wrong with that.

Ron Paul: Well, it came about because people generally in this country have lost confidence in freedom. Freedom really works and is very popular, but it lost its appeal because people became too dependent on government. As long as we were wealthy and able to borrow a lot of money, everybody did get a lot of stuff. But right now the conflict is that the government is bankrupt, the country is bankrupt, and a lot of people are starting to realize we don’t even trust the government anymore. And those are even the people who are on the receiving end. They don’t trust the government because here they are coming up, they’re giving us a trillion dollar of new programs and say they’re going to save money and cut the deficit. At the same time, they have Medicare and Medicaid and the post office all going bankrupt. They think the American people are going to believe this, and I think they’re naive if they think that people will believe this.

David Asman: Most Americans absolutely don’t believe that this thing will pay for itself, that it won’t do anything but dig us deeper into a hole. But I have to ask. Newt Gingrich came out with a piece today that began by saying “This will not stand”. That is, it will be overturned. What do you think the chances of it being overturned are?

Ron Paul: Not real good. Maybe parts of it will be. It’s really hard to reverse trends. I think it won’t stand for economic reasons. I think that our whole system is going to come unglued just because it doesn’t operate very well. And I think it will come unglued that way rather than us going back to the Hill and once again repealing this. But you know, if there’s a change in leadership in this country, at least in the Congress in November, maybe there will be an attempt to back off from this. But I’m not all that optimistic about it. I’m more concerned about what this bill will do to our financial condition of this country. I have been talking about that for a long time and this is just a horrendous new burden that we placed on the economy.

David Asman: By the way, talking about change of leadership,1 I got to ask, we have to wrap, but what about the chances of somebody named Rand Paul in Kentucky? What do you think his chances are?

Ron Paul: Tell you what, he’s doing a lot better than I expected at the beginning, he’s having a good time campaigning and the Republican leadership has done him a big favor, they’re campaigning for the other guy. The Washington politicians are campaigning for his opponent, so he’s doing very well. He’s attending most of the Tea Party meetings.

David Asman: We speak of course of Rand Paul, the son of Ron Paul. Ron Paul, wonderful to see you. Thank you for being here, Doctor.

Ron Paul: Thank you very much.

  • hi,hello my name john from just wanted be sure IIm autorized to post your post on my website thank you

  • Oh! Wow its genuinely a humorous and jockey YouTube video posted at this juncture. thanks for sharing it.

  • Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read something like this before. So good to find someone with some authentic thoughts on this subject. realy thanks for starting this up. this web site is something that’s needed on the internet, somebody with a bit of originality. helpful job for bringing something new to the internet!

  • Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your post seem to be running off the screen in Internet explorer. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The style and design look great though! Hope you get the problem resolved soon. Kudos

  • Test touches online casino beneath cream. The flesh tosses test in the evening tin circuit. The steep exit noses above test. The biased cylinder floors online casino. The insistence dies close to the flaw.

  • Fred the Protectionist

    Ron Paul: Obamacare will Damage Doctor-Patient Relationship”

    Why will ‘Obamacare damage doctor-patient relationship’?

    You know what’s great about Ron Paul? You can get everything you need out of the Title, or first sentence, of what Ron Paul says or writes. He never gets into a story, all you need is the title, there’s nothing else to the story.

    • Fred the Libertarian

      Maybe you should watch the video.

      • Fred the Protectionist


        Would there be any point.

    • Libertarian777

      DOCTOR Ron Paul is an OB/GYN

      I think he’s more qualified to speak about patient/doctor relationships than almost all of us on this forum.


      • Fred the Protectionist

        He may be, but he doesn’t communicate in depth on any issue.

  • endfight

    Because of the fact that the government grew to an oversized pig the people who work for the government don’t want to lose their job. So get prepared to lose your money and house if you don’t have money. This isn’t about the money suppy and crooked poloticians and crime. It is lack of God. Vote for people who put God first and problem is solved. If you don’t have God and won’t knock at his door, I am sorry for you. Look at the grave because you will be there and the life you led on earth will have been in vain. If you are too proud to give all the Glory to God through Jesus Christ then I am sorry for you. I will forgive all of you. God wanted a country to start fresh with founding principles. Europe is a place for the faint of soul and they should go. America is for those who believe in true freedom.

    • Ryan

      Ridiculous. And wrong. If the founders wanted a Theocracy they would have built a Theocracy. They didn’t. They wanted religius freedom, and freedom from religious persecution… Freedom from the same kind of narrow-of-purpose persecution you represent. Get a clue.

      • Fred the Protectionist

        The Godhaters vs. the bible thumpers, who will win this debate? Tune in tomorrow for details.

    • Ryan

      … Vote for people who put Constitution first, problem solved.

      Edit wouldn’t work so adding this.

  • Lawrence B. Beattie

    Obama Care would not even be a subject if we had true Free Enterprise.

    If the markets were truly open and competitive, including open to International companies, the cost would not be increasing faster than inflation, and coverage would not be decreasing.

    The intent of insurance is to pool the risk, where groups of people pay into a fund that would cover x percent those people who would have valid claims.

    But we have for profit companies that, by design, keep increasing premiums as much as competition allows, and refusing payment of claims as much as possible, including not covering people most likely to make a claim. These same companies spend millions of dollars influencing laws and regulations to their advantage.

    • Fred the Protectionist

      “Obama Care would not even be a subject if we had true Free Enterprise.”

      Obama Care would not even be a subject if the Libertarians hadn’t usurped and destroyed the Republican Party, the US manufacturing jobs, the middle class, etc etc.

      • longshotlouie

        Still deflecting the blame, Fled?

        • Fred the Protectionist

          Why do you hate America?

          • longshotlouie

            Why do you hate yourself?

          • Fred the Protectionist

            Stop hating and trying to destroy America. What did America every do to you?

          • Ryan

            Fraud the Pretenderist, admit it, when Ron Paul wins the Republican nomination for 2012 you will vote for him, gladly.

          • Fred the Protectionist

            Wishful thinking from Utopianists. Normal Americans don’t like Libertarians.

      • VR

        Would you be willing to read Economics in One Lesson by Henry Hazlitt? Here is a free copy.

      • SS

        Read the book, freddie
        You can do it!

        • & you should take Economics 101 to broaden your mind man.

    • They also influence lawmakers to make sure that they do make more profits and deny coverage for people who want it.

  • Patrick Hickey

    I agree with Mike Adams, “the health ranger” that the whole orthhodox medical system has come to the point of doing more harm than good (Health care reform bill dooms America to Pharma-dominated sickness and suffering

    I know things about Obama’s interactions with “The Business Rountable” that reveals just who Obama turns to for direction. What a consummate hypocrit.

    I realize you and your son are doing the best you can with what you have to work with, but at age 67, I don’t have time to mess with Obama care or orthodox medicine in general. I am on a path similar to that of Mike Adams. And with the corporate controlled media, it is impossible for us so-called citizens to believe the U.S. government is by the people and for the people.

    On top of all that, I am sustained by Social Security, a military pension, and Medicare is there in case I “break a leg”. If and when I find the government social safety-net programs are closed down, I might as well shoot myself in the head.

    Nevertheless, I do appreciate the fact that you and your son go out on a limb and point out that the emperor has no clothes! Thank you!

    • Libertarian777

      the emporer does have clothes!

      Remember the federal reserve can print unlimited amount of green clothes!


  • Ryan

    It’s funny when Ron Paul said, “The Republican leadership is doing him (Rand Paul) a huge favor for supporting the other guy.”
    So true! The neocons are toast just like the Dems, come November.
    Thank goodness, I think I see a glimmer of light at the end of the tunnel! Freedom is on the march!

    • Fred the Protectionist

      More libertarian doublethink. You libertarians are the neocons.

      *grabs your arms and starts making you punch your face in playful way* Stop hitting yourself, stop hitting yourself, stop hitting yourself.

      • Ryan

        Doublethink? Is that like thinking twice? Think twice, speak once! Sound advice, indeed. You ought to try it sometime. In your case, however, you ought to start by thinking once and work your way up to thinking twice.

        • Fred the Protectionist

          Doublethink is fervently believing in 2 contradictory items simultaneously.

          • longshotlouie

            Well then, you might want to stop that ‘double-think’, huh?

      • SS

        You might be a dullard,
        or extraodinarily simple.

        A victim of Nonthink.